Cody Asche hit a game-tying grand slam off Hutchison in the sixth to help the Phillies rally from a 5-0 deficit, but they were swept in a two-game portion of a four-game, home-and-home interleague series. The teams meet Wednesday night in Toronto.
Hutchison took a five-run lead into the sixth, but couldn't hold it. He stayed in the game after the slam, however, and retired the last seven batters he faced.
"It's really good to know he trusts me enough to go back out there," Hutchison said.
Hutchison allowed five runs and nine hits in eight innings in his seventh start since Tommy John surgery forced him to miss the 2013 season. Hutchison also got his first two career hits, both singles to left.
Jays manager John Gibbons was impressed with the way Hutchison pitched after giving up five runs.
"He showed us what he's all about," Gibbons said. "That's how you find out about a guy. He had two dominant innings."
Carlos Ruiz started the Phillies' rally in the sixth with a double and Chase Utley singled. Ryan Howard followed with an RBI single to cut it to 5-1. But Hutchison got the next two outs before pinch-hitter John Mayberry Jr. walked to load the bases. Asche then ripped a shot to the seats in right for his first career slam, tying it at 5.
"The biggest mistake was the walk," Hutchison said. "It's something I can't do again. A home run can happen, but a walk is in your control."
Asche finished 4 for 4.
Encarnacion drove one deep into the seats in left leading off the second to give the Blue Jays a 1-0 lead.
Jose Bautista led off the fourth with a double to left, advanced to third on Encarnacion's single through a shift and scored on Francisco's grounder for a 2-0 lead.
Rasmus hit a two-run shot out to right-center to make it 4-0 in the fourth. Steve Tolleson's RBI double in the sixth put the Blue Jays up 5-0.
Hamels hasn't looked too sharp in three starts after beginning the season on the disabled list because of biceps tendinitis. The three-time All-Star lefty was supposed to start Sunday but the flu pushed him back two days.
Hutchison became the third pitcher in Blue Jays history to have two hits in a game. David Cone did it in the 1992 World Series against Atlanta. Roy Halladay did it in 2007. ... The four hits and four RBIs for Asche are career highs. ... Bautista has reached safely in 33 straight games, the longest streak in the majors since Joey Votto's 33-game streak in 2011. ... Phillies SS Jimmy Rollins wasn't in the starting lineup for the second straight game because of a strained groin. He grounded out as a pinch-hitter. ... Cliff Lee (3-2, 3.00) opposes Mark Buehrle (5-1, 2.25) in a matchup of left-handed aces when the series shifts to Toronto on Wednesday night. The Phillies will play the 20,000th game in team history on Thursday.
Copyright by STATS LLC and The Associated Press
PHILADELPHIA, PA - MAY 6: Pitcher Drew Hutchison #36 of the Toronto Blue Jays throws a pitch in the bottom of the...