Mike McCall Jr. had 10 points and seven rebounds for the Billikens (23-6, 11-4 Atlantic 10), who moved a half-game behind first-place Temple in the league standings. The Owls, however, hold the tiebreaker, a 72-67 victory against St. Louis in January.
The Billikens clinched a top-four seed and bye in next week's Atlantic 10 tournament.
Xavier led 39-29 at halftime but shot just 28 percent (7 for 25) afterward. That helped St. Louis take control with a 24-2 run over an 8:34 second-half stretch.
Conklin had 11 points and McCall hit two 3-pointers during the surge, which gave the Billikens a 53-42 lead with 9:44 remaining. The Musketeers got no closer than seven points the rest of the way.
Get to know the NBA's next crop of superstars.
Marc Spears speaks with Chris Washburn, who was drafted third overall in the 1986 NBA Draft, about how drug addiction cost him almost everything, including his life.
Kentucky men's basketball coach John Calipari on Thursday apologized to Rick Pitino if the Cardinals coach interpreted his recent comment about scandals on campus as directed toward Louisville.