Lindsay and Robbins combined to score 11 of the 16 points in overtime by the Spiders (16-11, 6-6), but their biggest points came from Darien Brothers with 24 seconds left. The senior guard was fouled on a 3-point try and made all three free throws for a 79-77 lead.
Eric Mosley scored 30 points for the Bonnies (11-13, 4-7), who also lost in overtime Wednesday night, 69-66 to La Salle.
Richmond led by as many as 13 points, 49-36, and was ahead 61-51 with 6:40 remaining before St. Bonaventure (11-13, 4-7) rallied. Jordan Gathers, who had 18 points, made three baskets, Mosley hit a 3-pointer with 1:16 left and Charlon Kloof's free throw forced overtime.
Lindsay finished 14 of 14 from the free-throw line.
Colorado State graduate transfer John Gillon has chosen Syracuse, giving the Orange a potential starter at point guard entering the 2016-17 season.
DeSean Murray, who averaged 20.2 points as a sophomore at Presbyterian, will transfer to Auburn to play for coach Bruce Pearl.
Former Kentucky guard Ed Davender, the only Wildcat with at least 1,500 points and 400 assists, has died. He was 49.