| 1st Quarter | | BRWN | CLMB |
| Columbia at 15:00 | BRWN | CLMB |
| | Jon Rocholl kickoff for 44 yards returned by Steve Ziogas for 13 yards to the Brown 39, tackled by Andrew Kennedy. | 0 | 0 |
| Brown at 15:00 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at BRWN 39 | Bobby Sewall rush for 2 yards to the Brown 41, tackled by Alex Gross. | 0 | 0 |
| 2nd and 8 at BRWN 41 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Buddy Farnham for 11 yards to the Colum 48 for a 1ST down. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 48 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Bobby Sewall for 4 yards to the Colum 44, tackled by Andy Shalbrack and Conor Joyce. | | |
| 2nd and 6 at CLMB 44 | Bobby Sewall rush for 3 yards to the Colum 41, tackled by Drew Quinn. | | |
| 3rd and 3 at CLMB 41 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Bobby Sewall for 11 yards to the Colum 30 for a 1ST down, tackled by Alex Gross. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 30 | Jonathan Edwards rush for 2 yards to the Colum 28, tackled by Phillip Mitchell. | | |
| 2nd and 8 at CLMB 28 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Paul Raymond for 9 yards to the Colum 19 for a 1ST down, tackled by JoJo Smith. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 19 | Michael Dougherty rush for 2 yards to the Colum 17, tackled by Lou Miller and Eli Waltz. | | |
| 2nd and 8 at CLMB 17 | Michael Dougherty pass incomplete. | | |
| 3rd and 8 at CLMB 17 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Buddy Farnham for 17 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | 6 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan extra point GOOD. | 7 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan kickoff for 49 yards returned by Austin Knowlin for 7 yards to the Colum 28, tackled by Chris Perkins and Jesse Spartichino. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: BRWN drive: 10 plays 61 yards, 04:33 BRWN TD |
| |
| Columbia at 10:27 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 28 | Craig Hormann pass complete to Austin Knowlin for 8 yards to the Colum 36, tackled by John May. | 7 | 0 |
| 2nd and 2 at CLMB 36 | Craig Hormann pass complete to Taylor Joseph for 7 yards to the Colum 43 for a 1ST down, tackled by Anthony Martucci. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 43 | Ray Rangel rush for 22 yards to the Brown 35 for a 1ST down, tackled by Darrell Harrison. | | |
| 1st and 10 at BRWN 35 | Columbia penalty 10 yard holding accepted. | | |
| 1st and 20 at BRWN 45 | Craig Hormann rush for 9 yards to the Brown 36, tackled by Steve Ziogas. | | |
| 2nd and 11 at BRWN 36 | Craig Hormann pass incomplete to Andrew Kennedy, broken up by Frank Nuzzo. | | |
| 3rd and 11 at BRWN 36 | Craig Hormann pass complete to Taylor Joseph for 6 yards to the Brown 30, tackled by John May. | | |
| 4th and 5 at BRWN 30 | Craig Hormann pass incomplete to Andrew Kennedy, broken up by Frank Nuzzo. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: COL drive: 7 plays 42 yards, 00:00 COL DOWNS |
| |
| Brown at 10:27 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at BRWN 30 | Bobby Sewall rush for a loss of 4 yards to the Brown 26, tackled by Bayo Aregbe. | 7 | 0 |
| 2nd and 14 at BRWN 26 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Paul Raymond for 38 yards to the Colum 36 for a 1ST down, tackled by Eugene Edwards. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 36 | Tyler Rowley rush for 2 yards to the Colum 34, tackled by Conor Joyce. | | |
| 2nd and 8 at CLMB 34 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Bobby Sewall for 17 yards to the Colum 17 for a 1ST down, tackled by Alex Gross. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 17 | Michael Dougherty pass incomplete to Buddy Farnham, broken up by Eugene Edwards. | | |
| 2nd and 10 at CLMB 17 | Michael Dougherty rush for 5 yards to the Colum 12, tackled by Lou Miller and Grant Jefferson. | | |
| 3rd and 5 at CLMB 12 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Paul Raymond for 9 yards to the Colum 3 for a 1ST down, tackled by Bayo Aregbe. | | |
| 1st and Goal at CLMB 3 | Bobby Sewall rush for 3 yards for a TOUCHDOWN. | 13 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan extra point GOOD. | 14 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan kickoff for 54 yards returned by Austin Knowlin for 14 yards to the Colum 30, tackled by Darrell Harrison and Robert Gillett. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: BRWN drive: 8 plays 70 yards, 05:38 BRWN TD |
| |
| Columbia at 4:49 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 30 | Jordan E Davis rush for 2 yards to the Colum 32. | 14 | 0 |
| 2nd and 8 at CLMB 32 | Craig Hormann pass incomplete to Austin Knowlin, broken up by Darrell Harrison. | | |
| 3rd and 8 at CLMB 32 | Craig Hormann pass incomplete to Taylor Joseph. | | |
| 4th and 8 at CLMB 32 | Columbia penalty holding declined. | | |
| 4th and 8 at CLMB 32 | Jon Rocholl punt for 50 yards, returned by Buddy Farnham for 15 yards to the Brown 33, tackled by Alex Gross and Andrew Kennedy. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: COL drive: 3 plays 2 yards, 00:00 COL PUNT |
| |
| Brown at 4:49 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at BRWN 33 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Paul Raymond for 11 yards to the Brown 44 for a 1ST down, tackled by Andy Shalbrack and Eugene Edwards. | 14 | 0 |
| 1st and 10 at BRWN 44 | Bobby Sewall rush for 12 yards to the Colum 44 for a 1ST down, tackled by Eugene Edwards. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 44 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Colin Cloherty for 2 yards to the Colum 42. | | |
| 2nd and 8 at CLMB 42 | Columbia penalty 5 yard offside accepted. | | |
| 2nd and 3 at CLMB 37 | Michael Dougherty pass incomplete to Buddy Farnham, broken up by Adam Mehrer. | | |
| 3rd and 3 at CLMB 37 | Buddy Farnham rush for 3 yards to the Colum 34 for a 1ST down, tackled by Alex Gross and Eugene Edwards. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 34 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Bobby Sewall for a loss of 1 yard to the Colum 35, tackled by Augie Williams. | | |
| 2nd and 11 at CLMB 35 | Bobby Sewall rush for 2 yards to the Colum 33, tackled by Drew Quinn and Eugene Edwards. | | |
| 3rd and 9 at CLMB 33 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Buddy Farnham for 20 yards to the Colum 13 for a 1ST down, tackled by Augie Williams and Drew Quinn. | | |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 13 | Michael Dougherty pass incomplete to Bobby Sewall. | | |
| 2nd and 10 at CLMB 13 | Michael Dougherty pass complete to Bobby Sewall for 12 yards to the Colum 1 for a 1ST down, tackled by Andy Shalbrack. | | |
| 1st and Goal at CLMB 1 | Bobby Sewall rush for 1 yard for a TOUCHDOWN. | 20 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan extra point GOOD. | 21 | 0 |
| | Steve Morgan kickoff for 51 yards returned by Austin Knowlin for 25 yards to the Colum 44, tackled by Darrell Harrison. | | |
| DRIVE TOTALS: BRWN drive: 11 plays 67 yards, 03:22 BRWN TD |
| |
| Columbia at 0:18 | BRWN | CLMB |
| 1st and 10 at CLMB 44 | Ray Rangel rush for a loss of 4 yards to the Colum 40, tackled by Peter Hughes. | 21 | 0 |
| | End of 1st Quarter | | |
Brown 30, 
Columbia 22