After eight weeks on the bench, the journeyman was ready.
"Obviously, we were facing one of the best teams in the league," Hill said after the Rams surprised Denver 22-7 on Sunday. "Everybody stepped up, for sure."
The 34-year-old Hill got a game ball from coach Jeff Fisher after the Rams (4-6) beat an elite team for the third time this season. Hill kept it clean with a turnover-free outing that complemented a defense that had two interceptions and made the stops that counted.
Critical mistakes landed Austin Davis a spot on the bench. Hill needed two weeks to recover from a thigh injury that sidelined him in the opener, but after that he needed lots of patience.
"It's a constant process to stay up, especially as a backup, it's tough," Hill said. "But it's something you've got to do."
The Rams had already beaten the past two NFC champs -- Seattle and San Francisco. And they had blown big leads at home against the Cowboys and the first time they played the 49ers.
This time, they finished the job against the NFL's No. 2 offense, which hadn't scored fewer than 21 points and had scored 30 or more five of the previous six.
"It's not too bad to beat a guy who can put up 40 points in no time," defensive end Robert Quinn said. "He's a future Hall of Famer."
Rookie Tre Mason had 29 carries for 113 yards, the most against the Broncos' top-ranked run defense.
Manning was 34 for 54 for 389 yards with two interceptions, but was held to a 42-yard touchdown pass to Emmanuel Sanders, ending a streak of 15 consecutive games with at least two touchdown passes. He refused to lean on injuries that sidelined Julius Thomas, Montee Ball and Sanders.
"We didn't execute very well and I just think I didn't play very well," Manning said. "No excuses. I have to play better and we have to score more points than seven."
Demaryius Thomas had seven receptions for 103 yards, his seventh consecutive 100-yard game to match the Cowboys' Michael Irvin (1995) for second-longest single-season streak in NFL history. Calvin Johnson holds the record with eight straight.
The Broncos (7-3) failed twice on fourth down deep in St. Louis territory. Manning threw incomplete from the 37 in the first quarter and rookie Aaron Donald's sack helped end a drive in the fourth quarter on fourth-and-4 from the 28.
Quinn spun Manning around before Donald took the quarterback down.
"I got the opportunity to clean him up," Donald said. "You've got to take a big quarterback down when you can."
Julius Thomas (ankle) was sidelined in the first with two catches for 3 yards and ruled out in the third, Ball (groin) got limited work before aggravating an injury that kept him out the previous five games. Sanders (concussion) was ruled out after a hit from Rodney McLeod on a deep sideline throw in the third.
Hill was 20 for 29 for 220 yards and a touchdown with no interceptions in his first start since injuring a thigh in the first half of the opener.
The 34-year-old Hill guided a turnover-free offense.
"I certainly had the butterflies going," Hill said. "It was a lot of fun to be back out there."
Zuerlein hit three short field goals earlier, then connected from 55 and 53 yards in the fourth quarter. He last kicked five field goals in 2011 for Division II Missouri Western against Missouri Southern.
"Lots of times, you don't get many opportunities," Zuerlein said. "Today, they came in bunches."
LB Alec Ogletree and CB Trumaine Johnson had interceptions for St. Louis. Ogletree has an interception each of the last two games. ... Mason's 100-yard game was the first of his career and the third allowed by the Broncos this season. Denver had allowed 47.8 yards rushing the previous six games. ... The Broncos had won their previous nine games against losing teams dating to 2012. ... Manning has passed for 300 yards against every opponent. His best in three previous games against St. Louis, all with Indianapolis, was 235 yards passing in 2009. ... The Broncos had been the lone NFL team to go unbeaten on the road against teams with losing records since 2012 according to STATS, going 9-0.
Andrew Luck just agreed to the richest deal in NFL history. Is he worth it, and is a Super Bowl in his future?
ESPN business analyst Andrew Brandt offers his take on whether it was the right move for the Colts to sign Andrew Luck to a contract extension at this time.
Former Cleveland Browns quarterback Johnny Manziel told TMZ Sports he plans to sober up starting next month, a vow a source says he is serious about.
Adam Schefter explains the financial significance of Andrew Luck's new contract, especially as it relates to future deals for quarterbacks.
Using a medicine ball rather than a regular volleyball, James Harrison and a few friends find a new way to exercise upper body strength.
What did the Colts prove by giving Andrew Luck the largest deal in NFL history? They believe what happened in 2015, his worst season, was a fluke.